Show 17

Show 17MLB The Show 17 bats the ball out of the park

With the Major League Baseball season just underway, it’s time to break out your baseball bat, glove, and ball with MLB The Show 17—available exclusively on PlayStation 4. Developed by the team over at San Diego Studios, MLB The Show 17 packs big changes to Franchise Modes, Road To The Show, Diamond Dynasty, and the addition of Retro Mode.

Quite possibly one of the best baseball simulation games ever, let’s take a look at how MLB The Show 17 ups the ante over last years’ game.

A game that just keeps getting better year after year

When you are the only simulation baseball game on the market, it can be difficult to avoid falling into a state of complacency. Sometimes it seems as if yearly sports titles are nothing more than roster updates from developers, and that can be a major turn off for potential players.

Game Details

Platform(s): PlayStation 4
Developer: SIE San Diego Studios
Publisher: Sony Interactive Entertainment
Genre: Sports
Modes: Single-player, multiplayer
ESRB Rating: E (Everyone)

It’s been four years since MLB The Show has been the only choice for baseball fans looking for a true simulation. Since then, the franchise has done an amazing job of improving year after year.

The Show‘s three main modes Franchise, Road To The Show, and Diamond Dynasty all return to MLB The Show 17—each one of them seeing improvements in various ways.

Show 17Franchise Mode comes with some improvements

Franchise Mode doesn’t contain much in terms of big new features—but the additions do help you if you are looking to progress through seasons quicker. You can play through games locked down on a specific player and use the new quick manage feature that allows you to act as a manager without ever stepping on the field.

Additionally, you can take part in major moments of a specific game via the new critical situations option that stops a game sim when something needs your attention. The new player quirks also offer a new way to manage your team, as they help you better understand the type of players of your roster and who you may want or not want to target in the future.

Road To The Show gets meaningful upgrades

Out of all the modes, Road To The Show has arguably seen the most improvements this year. It has been changed to a full fledged RPG style mode, and is now shown as if you are watching a documentary. The narrator describes a situation that is playing out on the screen, while you have the ability to select dialogue responses via a conversation window on the screen.

From doing what is good for the team to looking out for yourself as a player, you now have various ways to advance your career. Honestly, I found that the new dialogue options in Road To The Show to became repetitive after several hours of play, and often zoned out because of the predictable nature of events.

Show 17

Retro mode—perfect for pickup and play

The new major addition to MLB The Show 17 is Retro mode, which allows you to just pickup and play. Available only as a quick play mode, Retro mode is perfect when you want to play with friends that don’t really care about the finer aspects of baseball.

Other modes such as Challenge of the Week, Online Franchise, and Home Run Derby are also present in MLB The Show 17.

Show 17

Diamond Dynasty upgraded

Diamond Dynasty, while much the same as last year, gets a number of small yet rewarding improvements. First, the customization options for your team have improved greatly—allowing you to have the most unique team possible. Furthermore, the logo creation tools are one of the best in-game creation tools across any sports game.

In addition, Diamond Dynasty features over 2000 player cards to collect and a number of new ways to earn XP cards and stubs throughout—without the need to invest more money. For those new to MLB The Show franchise, Diamond Dynasty is very similar to the Ultimate Team mode from EA Sports games. I’d have to say that Diamond Dynasty contains one of the best card based modes in a sports game.

Show 17

Realistic presentation

When it comes to presentation, MLB The Show 17 is spot on in recreating the actual baseball experience. Matt Vasgersian returns as voice of MLB The Show, and two new members join the broadcast booth, Harold Reynolds and Dan Plesac. The addition of two new voices and tandem with the full MLB Network broadcast branding increases the overall authenticity of a real baseball game that only MLB The Show 17 can offer.

It’s important to note, now that MLB The Show is no longer releasing on the PlayStation 3, it is easy to see how much more the developers were able to get out of the PlayStation 4 with MLB The Show 17. You can really tell the difference visually between last year’s game and MLB The Show 17. Players look more detailed than ever before, and it is as if the game has jumped to the next generation of hardware.

Replays allow you to browse ballparks and zoom in and out on players during different moments. It really highlights just how incredible the game looks. From the batting physics to the numerous new animations, you can see that focusing on one version of the game makes a big difference.

Show 17

Online play is a work in progress

Online play is pretty much the same as it has been for the past several games. Common issues are still present, and significant amounts of lag are quite frequent when playing. Common actions such as fielding, pitching or even taking a swing at the ball become a headache.

Things like getting balls stuck against the wall or players not leaving the batter’s box on hits, leave the online play big room for improvement. Though I must say, since MLB The Show 17’s release—I’ve seen improvements in online play. It this that has left me hopeful that these online issues could be ironed out in the near future.

Show 17

Final Thoughts

I haven’t been this excited for a sports game in a very long time, and I was completely blown away when I fired up MLB The Show 17 for the first time. There is without a doubt no other baseball game that even comes close to offering the same caliber experience, which MLB The Show 17 does.

The team at San Diego Studios has yet again expanded upon the best baseball game franchise on the market. MLB The Show 17 has set the bar that all baseball simulation games should be measured by. With 30 teams, hundreds of players, and more updates to this year’s game than I can count on my hands—MLB The Show 17 is a baseball fan’s dream come true game.

Let me know in the comment section below what your favourite new addition to MLB The Show 17 you like the most. And remember, always keep swinging!

+ Retro Mode is a fantastic blast from the past
+ Graphics and physics have been greatly improved upon
+ A plethora of game modes to chose and play from
+ The best baseball sim available on home consoles

– Frequent server and online issues


Gameplay: 4.5/5
Graphics: 4.5/5
Sound: 4/5
Lasting Appeal/Replayability: 5/5

Overall Rating 4.5/5 (90%)

Get MLB The Show 17 for PlayStation 4
Get MLB The Show 17: MVP Edition for PlayStation 4

Jon Scarr
Jon is the Gaming Editor and is based in Toronto. He is a proud Canadian who has a serious passion for gaming. He is a veteran of the video game and tech industry with over 20 years experience. You can often find Jon streaming the latest games on his YouTube channel. Jon loves to talk about gaming and tech, come say hi and join the conversation with Jon on Threads @4ScarrsGaming and @4Scarrsgaming on Instagram.


  1. Thanks Jon, the game looks and sounds amazing!

    I used to really be into sports games because each game was never the same based on how/who you played. Only problem was I was SO good, I couldn’t find a proper challenger…..know anyone?

Comments are closed.