Dark Pictures Anthology Devil in Me Review BannerAre you ready to face your fears? Get ready for a spine-tingling journey as you play The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me. This thrilling horror experience is shrouded in mystery, as you step into the shoes of a film crew documenting the life and times of serial killer H.H. Holmes. Your choices determine how the story plays out as you explore eerie locations, interact with strange characters, and uncover dark secrets. The Devil in Me definitely knows how to serve up the scares and will keep you on the edge of your seat. Let’s put on a brave face and dive into Supermassive Games‘ latest horror offering with my full review.

The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me DetailsDark Pictures Anthology Devil in Me PS5 Cover

Platform(s): PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series and PC
Developer(s): Supermassive Games
Publisher (s): Bandai Namco Entertainment
Genre: Survival-horror game
Modes: Single-player, multiplayer
ESRB Rating: M (Mature, 17 years and over)

The Devil in Me Storyline

Supermassive Games has crafted another captivating story as part of “The Dark Pictures Anthology” series, one that is hard to put down. The developer is no stranger to tales of macabre, with games like Man of Medan, Little Hope, and House of Ashes in the anthology. Supermassive also recently released The Quarry, which falls outside of the series, but is a similar survival horror and gameplay style that shouldn’t be missed.

Dark Pictures Anthology Devil in Me Prolong1800s prologue: the devil shows his face

This time around The Devil in Me centres around serial killer H.H. Holmes and his notorious World’s Fair Hotel. Holmes created what has been coined the “Murder Castle,” a building full of traps into which he would lure victims into. The game’s prologue takes place in 1893, and introduces players to Holmes and his sadistic ways.

Dark Pictures Anthology Devil in Me Modern HorrorA modern horror story

After this, the story fast forwards to October 2022, and you play as a crew of 5 documentary filmmakers hired to create a TV series about “famous murderers.” As a team, you are tasked with focusing on Holmes and his victims to produce content for the show. At first, things move slowly with few leads until you receive an invitation to film at Granthem Du’Met’s estate. He has built a replica of Holmes’ notorious “Murder Castle” on a secluded island. The crew, cautious but desperate for footage accepts the invitation to the estate. Once they arrive things start to go wrong, and the group is separated and trapped in the replica Murder Castle by a mysterious figure. It’s up to you to evade the killer and make the right choices to help get the entire group out alive.

Devil in Me gameplayDevil in Me gameplay

The gameplay this time around is similar to the other titles in The Dark Pictures Anthology, save for a few minor additions. You play as a group of characters who must survive the unknown horrors that await. Players are presented with choices that can shape the outcome of each character’s fate, so choosing wisely is important. Gameplay revolves around light exploration and utilizing quick time events (QTE) to stay alive and progress through the story with the help of a branching dialogue system. The new addition to the gameplay is a new inventory system that contains character specific items. For example, one character can use a business card to pick locks, while another can use a lighter to find their way in the dark. These different character-specific tools can help you when attempting to solve puzzles or avoid danger.

The Devil In Me MultiplayerDial M for multiplayer

The game also offers online cooperative mode options where players can team up with a friend and work together to survive the castle. There are two different ways you play through the story with friends, “Movie Night Mode” and “Shared Story.” Movie Night Mode has you and up to 4 friends pass a single controller and take turns progressing the story. If you want to play with another person online, Shared Story mode is the way to go. You and a friend can work together, to progress the story and survive.

Dark Pictures Anthology Devil in Me GraphicsGraphics and audio design

The visual presentation overall is great, setting the tone for an atmosphere that is appropriately unsettling. From flickering lights to pitch black corridors and hair-raising audio design, you feel like you’re in the centre of a horror movie. Character models look great but the animations and expressions are a little stiff. This along with some of the performances made it hard to get as invested as I did with characters in Supermassive’s previous games. The setting itself looks great, and the muder castle environment is filled with secrets to discover as you traverse the interior and surrounding area.

Devil in Me GoreThe audio design does an excellent job of bringing the horror elements to life, with booming sound effects and intense music that heightens the tension. Voice acting is mostly decent, but some performances can be a bit hallow at times. Aside from that, the sound design does a great job in helping to set an atmosphere of dread and unease.

Final ThoughtsFinal thoughts on The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me

The Devil in Me is an interesting spin on the series, with one of it’s best premises yet. It looks great, creates a spooky atmosphere and offers horror fans some enjoyable gameplay with its QTE and new inventory system. Its branching dialogue system allows you to shape your own story, while cooperative play makes it even more intense with friends. While the performances can be somewhat lacking at times, it still manages to remain an entertaining horror experience that will have you on your toes. In the end, Devil in Me is definitely worth checking out for any fan of Supermassive Games or horror games in general.

-Great visuals, setting the tone for a spooky atmosphere.
-Cooperative play makes it even more intense with a friend.
-New inventory system enables characters to have their own tools to solve puzzles and avoid danger

-QTEs add tension and excitement as you try to make it out alive
-Some performances can be stiff or lacking at times
-The branching dialogue system can feel a bit too linear in some sections

Overall assessment of The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me

Gameplay: 3/5
Graphics: 3.5/5
Sound: 4/5
Lasting Appeal/Replayability: 3.5/5

Overall Rating 3.5/5 (70%)

Purchase The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me

Click here to see the full line of video game software available at Bestbuy.ca
Click here to see digital video game downloads offered at BestBuy.ca

A copy of the game was provided by the developer for the purpose of this review.

Matthew Rondina
Matthew has been involved in all things tech related since the start of the digital era. He shares his passion for technology in his day job as a teacher and via multiple media platforms. As a long-time veteran of the video game and tech industry, he's covered interactive entertainment and esports on the web, in video series, podcasts, and on international television. You can follow Matthew's tech-venture filled lifestyle on twitter, instagram @dapper_tux.